Tucked away in Old Town, The Paradise Inn is the ideal home base for any Key West getaway. Our adults-only hotel is steps away from everything that makes this Florida island special. Ride around on moped rentals stopping along the way to explore different attractions. When hunger starts to set in, you have plenty of dining options to choose from throughout Key West, including phenomenal pizza spots.

The 5 Best Restaurants in Key West for a Slice

While vacations are the best time to try something new, sometimes there’s nothing better than a cheesy, comforting slice of pizza. The pizza restaurants in Key West have everything from classic toppings to something a little more inventive.

  1.  Onlywood Pizzeria has been plating up incredible pizzas in authentic Neapolitan style since 2012. All of their creations are cooked inside a brick oven, giving them their signature crust and flavor.
  2. Roosctia Wood-Fire Pizzeria creates is dough with soft-grain flour, fresh yeast, water, and sea salt to make their dough. This is then topped with a range of flavors to create a tasty variety of pies.
  3. Get dinner and dessert in one spot at Duetto Pizza & Gelato. Browse the menu, and you’ll find everything from eggplant parmigiana pizza to the classic Margherita. Be sure to leave room for some creamy gelato.
  4. For a unique pizza experience, head to Clemente’s Trolley Pizzeria. Found inside a vintage trolley, this Key West spot has a menu filled with pizza, pasta, and more.
  5. Big Cheezees Chilin Grill is as unique as its name. The White Street restaurant has a menu filled with so many pizza options you’ll have a hard time picking just one.

Consider grabbing your pie to go and enjoying back in the comfort of your Key West hotel room.

Plan a Memorable Escape to Key West

The pool of a Key West hotel to relax by while eating pizza.Whatever adventures you’re looking for, you’re sure to find something that fits the bill near The Paradise Inn. During your adventures, satisfy your craving by grabbing a sweet treat from a local bakery or picking up a pizza from a nearby Key West restaurant. 

Our charming hotel in the heart of Old Town is the perfect home base for any getaway. Featuring a range of suites and cottages, our variety of accommodations means you can find the perfect space for your group. Snack on your pizza out by the pool, complete with something to drink from our nightly wine and cheese happy hour. After checking out our special offers, call 877-819-4622 to reserve your stay.